| More
Home / Food Police / Headlines


January 17, 2007
printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list


Why Crash Diets Crash

Dieters struggling to change their food habits may now be able to say "so long" to extreme measures like cabbage soup and electro-shock therapy. New research shows efforts directed at eliminating types of food may be focused on the wrong target. Yesterday a Wall Street Journal columnist suggested that "what" you eat does not matter as much as "how":

There's a lot of evidence that simply changing your habits and attention level while eating can make a difference in the quantity of food you ingest. In the new book "Mindless Eating," researcher Brian Wansink, director of the Cornell University Food and Brand Lab in Ithaca, N.Y., argues that external factors -- such as family habits, food packaging, distractions and even the location of food on the table -- often influence eating habits more than hunger.

Last year in The New York Times Wansink suggested that easy and effective changes in the size of plates used or the type of wine served at a meal "have little to do with matters that consume nutrition researchers." Based on this argument, foie gras bans, fat prohibitions and mandatory calorie counts may be examples of food police making maxims out of molehills.

When asked for his opinion on the recent flurry of food legislation, Wansink said, "so much of the answer lies not in counting calories, not in legislating, but in the middle range of what we can do by changing some of our own habits."

email us comments




printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list

Daily Headlines

  • Taxing “Junk Food” Is Trashy Policy
    Posted On: Tuesday 3/16/2010
  • Hype Masters Call Out Corn Syrup Falsehoods
    Posted On: Thursday 3/11/2010
  • Food Cops Prepare for Round 2
    Posted On: Wednesday 3/3/2010
  • A Stimulus for Food Cops' Appetites
    Posted On: Wednesday 2/17/2010
  • The White House: Food Police Headquarters?
    Posted On: Friday 2/12/2010
  • Personal Responsibility Still Ahead?
    Posted On: Thursday 2/11/2010
  • CSPI: Kings of Gripe
    Posted On: Tuesday 2/9/2010


  • Activist Cash

    Kelly Brownell
    Background
    Kelly Brownell is a Yale psychologist on a decade-long crusade against what he calls America’s “toxic food environment.” He is best known for having first proposed the infamous “Twinkie tax.” read more here »

    Marion Nestle
    Background
    Marion Nestle is one of the country’s most hysterical anti-food-industry fanatics. She writes: “Sellers of food products do not attract the same kind of attention as purveyors of drugs or tobacco. They should.” read more here »

    OpEds

    ‘Tis not the season to be annoyingly wary
    This time of year, people watching their weight while facing down holiday happy hours and open houses can be particularly susceptible to scaremongering by the fat police. read more here »

    High-sodium food fight
    It doesn't take a Ph.D. in nutrition to know that a pile of pancakes, sausage, bacon and eggs is not a healthy breakfast. Except, apparently, when it comes to the nutritionists at the Center for Science in the Public Interest. read more here »


    Copyright © 1997-2010 Center for Consumer Freedom. Tel: 202-463-7112.