printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list


Road to Nanny State Paved With Bad Intentions?

Road to Nanny State Paved With Bad Intentions?

California is abuzz this week about matters of public health. Like many other news outlets, the Orange County Register editorialized against the state’s recent Crisco prohibition, citing economist Walter Williams’ comments on a similar ban in New York City last year:

They’ve started out with a small target -- a ban on restaurant use of trans fats. ... If banning a fat that’s only 2 percent of our daily caloric intake is wonderful, why not ban saturated fats, the intake of which is much higher? Then there’s the size of restaurant servings. Instead of a law simply requiring restaurants to label the calories in a meal, there will be laws setting a legal limit on portions.

Williams makes an excellent point. But forget, for a moment, about outlawing trans fats. Even forget about just curbing serving sizes. Lawmakers seem to have lost interest in merely restricting our choices on restaurant menus. Now, they’re trying to limit our choice of restaurants instead.

The Los Angeles City Council voted this week to ban “fast food” restaurants from certain neighborhoods, and support for this kind of “health zoning” is rapidly surfacing in other major cities too. Overzealous health officials seem frightfully unaware that, as William Saletan of Slate magazine explained, “The war on fat has just crossed a major red line.”

There’s a vital lesson hidden in all of this. Small regulations here (mandating calorie counts) and there (outlawing fois gras) may seem insignificant. But LA’s “fast food” ban shows the process by which those little changes ultimately amount to a chokehold on individual freedom. So while obesity activists commonly employ fear and turpitude to advance their draconian agenda, their biggest successes are often the result of simple indifference.

Policies like soda taxes, menu labels, and ingredient regulation seldom provoke public outrage -- at least not right away. These things accumulate ingredient by ingredient, drip by drip, freedom by freedom.

email us comments




printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list

Daily Headlines

  • Soda Scam Goes Hollywood
    Posted On: Friday 11/6/2009
  • Crushing Beverage Tax Proposals
    Posted On: Tuesday 10/27/2009
  • The Empire State Strikes Back?
    Posted On: Wednesday 10/21/2009
  • Quote of the Week
    Posted On: Tuesday 10/20/2009
  • Another Big Sham in the Big Apple
    Posted On: Friday 10/16/2009
  • Doubling Down on L.A. Zoning Bans
    Posted On: Monday 10/12/2009
  • Labeling a Failure
    Posted On: Friday 10/9/2009
  • Start Spreadin’ the News: No New Soda Taxes
    Posted On: Thursday 10/8/2009


  • OpEds

    Obesity not about fast food, but exercise
    State-by-state obesity trends make more sense when you look at the other side of the obesity equation: physical activity. Simply put, residents of states with high obesity rates tend to move less. read more here »

    Controlling obesity: Exercise, or lack of it, critical factor
    State-by-state obesity trends make more sense when you look at the other side of the obesity equation — physical activity. Simply put, residents of states with high obesity rates tend to move less read more here »


    Copyright © 1997-2009 Center for Consumer Freedom. Tel: 202-463-7112.