Resize Font Increase Font Size Decrease Font Size Reset Font Size

Home / Food Police / Headlines

June 4, 2002
printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list


CSPI And Brownell: Two Twinkies In One Package

"If children have healthy foods available, they'll eat healthy foods. If they have unhealthy foods available, they'll eat those… Animals will do the same thing when put in a cage."

That was Kelly Brownell, mullah of the "Twinkie tax," in testimony before the U.S. Senate in late May. It's the latest silly rhetoric from one of the grand poobahs of the anti-consumer movement. Some of Brownell's greatest hits:

  • "Children are to the obesity field what second-hand smoke was to tobacco."

  • "There is no difference between Ronald McDonald and Joe Camel… we have to start thinking about this in a more militant way."

  • "Congress and state legislatures could shift the focus to the environment by taxing foods with little nutritional value. Fatty foods would be judged on their nutritive value per calorie or gram of fat. The least healthy would be given the highest tax rate… Consumption of high-fat food would drop."

    So who is Kelly Brownell? He's one of the mainstays of the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI), the infamous activist group that wants "taxes on snack foods and soft drinks," dubbed fettuccini Alfredo a "heart attack on a plate," and has trashed Chinese food, popcorn, pizza, and many other popular dishes. CSPI's members are no blushing flowers when it comes to telling you what to eat (and, more often, what not to eat). [For more on CSPI, visit CSPIscam.com.]

    While some CSPI members say Brownell is not a part of their organization, Brownell is to CSPI as Peter Parker is to Spiderman:

  • Brownell and CSPI head Michael Jacobson together penned a 2000 American Journal of Public Health piece arguing that "a steep tax would probably reduce the consumption of the taxed foods and could be used to generate funding to subsidize healthful foods," but "a small tax may be more politically feasible and would mostly go unnoticed by the public."

  • Brownell has written for CSPI's Nutrition Action Healthletter, the organization's primary product. Brownell also sits on the publication's Scientific Advisory Board.

  • Brownell and Jacobson have worked together on an anti-McDonald's campaign, anti-sugar efforts, and "Twinkie tax" proposals.

    CSPI and Brownell want nothing less than what some anti-consumer activists call "a retooling of our environment" that limits choices. That means taxes, marketing restrictions, zoning restrictions, advertising bans, and more.

  • email us comments



    printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list
    Headlines


    An "A-Salt" On New Yorkers
    Posted On: Tuesday 9/30/2008

    Nestle's Kernel of Common Sense
    Posted On: Thursday 9/25/2008

    Junk Science: The Food Cop Pick-Me-Up
    Posted On: Wednesday 9/24/2008

    Cereal Killer? HAH!
    Posted On: Friday 9/19/2008

    Dr. Joe To The Rescue!
    Posted On: Monday 9/15/2008

    Food Cops Flip-Flop
    Posted On: Thursday 9/4/2008

    Nutrition Nannies: A Brief History
    Posted On: Tuesday 9/2/2008

    Quote of the Day
    Posted On: Wednesday 8/20/2008

    David vs. Goliath
    Posted On: Tuesday 8/19/2008


    ActivistCash.com

    Kelly Brownell
    Background
    Kelly Brownell is a Yale psychologist on a decade-long crusade against what he calls America’s “toxic food environment.” He is best known for having first proposed the infamous “Twinkie tax.” read more here »

    Marion Nestle
    Background
    Marion Nestle is one of the country’s most hysterical anti-food-industry fanatics. She writes: “Sellers of food products do not attract the same kind of attention as purveyors of drugs or tobacco. They should.” read more here »

    Op-Eds

    What's on the menu? Regulation
    There are ways to ensure that consumers have access to a surplus of information without having it thrust in their faces on restaurant menus. read more here »

    Preserve right to eat without guilt: Don't post calories of fast-food dishes
    Americans should still have a right to guilt-free eating. read more here »


    About Us | Contact Us | Please Help Us | Site Map
    Ad Campaigns | Press Center | Daily News Archive | Email Subscription | Op-Eds | Cartoons | Games | Link To Us
    Copyright © 1997-2008 Center for Consumer Freedom. Tel: 202-463-7112.