Resize Font Increase Font Size Decrease Font Size Reset Font Size

Home / Big Government / Headlines

January 15, 2007
printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list


Government-Mandated Fad Diets?

Could long waits at the DMV soon be matched by time spent standing in anti-bread lines? Sure, if government-mandated Atkins diets turn carbohydrates into contraband. Though bread bans seem laughable right now, laws like New York City's trans fat ban illustrate policymakers' predilection for governing by trends, as an online Washington Post op-ed argues today:
By singling out one substance, the city is sending a dangerous message that health is about eliminating "bad" foods rather than making better lifestyle choices. This is the policy equivalent of a fad diet -- it will grab the headlines for a short while without changing anyone's actual behavior.

Motivation for banning "bad" foods extends beyond legislators' desire to fit the public into skinny jeans. Since laws against cheap, fast food disproportionately affect the poor, it's not hard to catch a whiff of elitism emanating from the halls of power. Claiming the poor "are the torchbearers of an emerging new class system based on nutrition," a Sydney Morning Herald column alleged last week that weight may provide the last acceptable grounds for discrimination. Obesity, then, supplies justification for wealthy citizens and lawmakers to pass "elitist snap judgments" based on the contents of a shopping cart or lunch order.

Luckily, not everyone flaunts food scares to mask feelings of moral superiority, and many people do not regard pastries or pie as social currency. One resident of Delaware may speak for the silent majority who still believes that sometimes a cigar is just a cigar. Responding to a question by the News Journal about ordering food that might contain trans fat, Ogletown resident Marie Wheeler says, "I think about it ... Then I just order the french fries anyway."

email us comments



printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list
Headlines


Declaration of Food Independence
Posted On: Thursday 7/2/2009

Kids’ Health Can Be Saved By The Recess Bell
Posted On: Monday 6/29/2009

Know Thy Self, Know Thy Nanny
Posted On: Wednesday 6/24/2009

Senate Still Contemplating Unpopular Pop Tax
Posted On: Monday 6/15/2009

CDC Nominee Faces Consumer Backlash
Posted On: Monday 5/18/2009

Thomas Frieden: The End of Personal Health?
Posted On: Friday 5/15/2009

Quote of the Week
Posted On: Thursday 5/14/2009

Food Dogma, With a 'Nudge'
Posted On: Wednesday 5/13/2009

USGS Mercury Study Lacks Seafood Standing
Posted On: Monday 5/4/2009


Op-Eds

Obesity not about fast food, but exercise
State-by-state obesity trends make more sense when you look at the other side of the obesity equation: physical activity. Simply put, residents of states with high obesity rates tend to move less. read more here »

Controlling obesity: Exercise, or lack of it, critical factor
State-by-state obesity trends make more sense when you look at the other side of the obesity equation — physical activity. Simply put, residents of states with high obesity rates tend to move less read more here »


About Us | Contact Us | Please Help Us | Site Map
Ad Campaigns | Press Center | Daily News Archive | Email Subscription | Op-Eds | Cartoons | Games | Link To Us
Copyright © 1997-2009 Center for Consumer Freedom. Tel: 202-463-7112.