Resize Font Increase Font Size Decrease Font Size Reset Font Size

Home / Food Police / Headlines

August 31, 2007
printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list


Government Mandated Guilt

Government Mandated Guilt

Last year, Slate magazine outlined America's slow march to diet despotism by describing activists' strategy to wage war on "junk food": "First, we should protect kids. Second, fat people are burdening the rest of us. Third, junk food isn't really food." Since then, food cops have pressed for government regulations on children's advertising and speculated on the economic burden of love handles. Now they're reaching out to strip food of its sanctity.

Food fulfills a basic human need and provides a great deal of pleasure. But the nutrition interventions concocted by food activists -- aimed at living longer, not living better -- suck the fun out of eating. For instance, the nutrition zealots at the Center for the Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) have a long history of demonizing anything that tastes good, labeling it "junk food" or even "food porn." The latest example of these pleasure-sucking campaigns comes from the proposed mandating of warning labels on restaurant menus.

The group's nutrition policy director, Margo Wootan, has justified the moralistic mandate: "Californians, and indeed all Americans, deserve to know what they're getting when they're ordering food." Ignoring the detailed nutritional information that most restaurants already provide to customers, CSPI defines "what they're getting" with just one word: calories. Dictating calorie counts reduces the value of a meal to a measure of energy. But anyone who's ever enjoyed a snow cone on a hot day or shared a bottle of wine at a romantic dinner knows that food is much more than that.

British researcher David Warburton, who studies the relationship between health and pleasure, seconds that notion. His studies have found that pleasurable experiences hold restorative properties for people suffering from life-threatening illnesses, like AIDS and cancer. On the other hand, guilt places incredible stress on the body and severely compromises the immune system. (And CSPI is essentially lobbying for government-mandated guilt.)

CSPI has also proposed "traffic light" labeling systems for packaged foods, already unfolding in places like Europe and New Zealand. These labels reduce the merit of different grocery items to colored dots: red for "bad" and green for "good." Like the warning labels on menus, this black-and-white approach harms people's relationship with food and promotes eating disorders.

Maybe someone should clue in the nutrition "experts": Good food isn't just about staying alive. It's about enjoying life too.

email us comments



printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list
Headlines


Declaration of Food Independence
Posted On: Thursday 7/2/2009

Obesity Watchdogs Fail To Answer Weight-Gain Questions
Posted On: Wednesday 7/1/2009

Kids’ Health Can Be Saved By The Recess Bell
Posted On: Monday 6/29/2009

Know Thy Self, Know Thy Nanny
Posted On: Wednesday 6/24/2009

'Let Obama Eat Burgers'
Posted On: Thursday 6/18/2009

Quote of the Week
Posted On: Wednesday 6/17/2009

Kids Wise Up To Moderate Eating (With No Thanks To Snack Police)
Posted On: Tuesday 6/16/2009

Clip of the Week: The Worst Cover of All TIME
Posted On: Friday 6/12/2009

‘You Can’t Get Buff If You’re On Your Duff’
Posted On: Tuesday 6/2/2009


ActivistCash.com

Kelly Brownell
Background
Kelly Brownell is a Yale psychologist on a decade-long crusade against what he calls America’s “toxic food environment.” He is best known for having first proposed the infamous “Twinkie tax.” read more here »

Marion Nestle
Background
Marion Nestle is one of the country’s most hysterical anti-food-industry fanatics. She writes: “Sellers of food products do not attract the same kind of attention as purveyors of drugs or tobacco. They should.” read more here »

Op-Eds

‘Prevention’ at the New CDC: How Far Is Too Far?
Do Americans really share Frieden's ambition to prevent every disease at any cost? The doc's killjoy reputation strongly suggests that the answer is "no." read more here »

BMI 'report cards' won't keep kids healthy
In the campaign to eradicate childhood obesity, schools around the country have banned everything from birthday treats to vending machines. But when it comes to slimming down students, the so-called food police aren't making much progress. read more here »


About Us | Contact Us | Please Help Us | Site Map
Ad Campaigns | Press Center | Daily News Archive | Email Subscription | Op-Eds | Cartoons | Games | Link To Us
Copyright © 1997-2009 Center for Consumer Freedom. Tel: 202-463-7112.