Resize Font Increase Font Size Decrease Font Size Reset Font Size

Home / Seafood / Headlines

October 13, 2008
printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list


Greenpeace Science: Fishy and Illiterate, As Usual

Greenpeace Science: Fishy and Illiterate, As Usual

Relax, lovers of fish sticks, breaded-filet sandwiches, and imitation crab. The ocean’s supply of pollock, the world’s most ubiquitous flaky white fish, is just fine. But you wouldn’t know it from listening to the scientifically challenged activists at Greenpeace. The group warned Reuters this weekend that “the pollock fishery is on the fast-track to collapse” and blanketed the planet with an apocalyptic press release claiming: “We are on the cusp of one of the largest fishery collapses in history.” Scary stuff. Good thing it’s not true.

The National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) has a one-word answer to the question of whether pollock are overfished: “No.” And the Marine Stewardship Council certifies pollock from the Gulf of Alaska and the Bering Sea as “sustainable.” So what the heck is Greenpeace talking about?

Last week NMFS released the results of its annual survey of pollock in the Bering Sea. And on the surface, it looks like Greenpeace may have something alarm-worthy. As The Seattle Times notes, the survey indicates that “the 2008 pollock population was 38 percent below last year’s survey levels.”

But this is where Greenpeace and some reporters understand just enough science to be dangerous. Take it from NMFS biologist Jim Ianelli, who conducted the survey. He told Seafood Source that the survey:

“… represents only one piece of the data used in the analysis … Indications are that the 2006 year-class [pollock hatched in that year] are well above average.”

Catch that? Greenpeace is running rampant with what might be the only piece of bad news in a “bigger picture” that looks … well, pretty good.

How did Greenpeace get this so wrong? As Ianelli explained on Friday to Intrafish, ocean temperatures have been dropping for three straight years. This means more of the fish swim very close to the ocean floor to keep warm, skewing the survey results.

“[F]or the assessment numbers that get presented, we only go down to three meters from the bottom,” said Ianelli.

The groundfish survey surveys the bottom, and when those numbers are calculated, estimates were 92 percent of the biomass that was expected, he said.

If you’re wondering why Greenpeace—a group that’s supposed to be well-versed in the science of things warming and cooling—would willfully ignore such a basic facet of fisheries science, wonder no more. It’s all about raising money. Friday afternoon we received an urgent-sounding e-mail from the group, featuring the dire warning that the pollock situation “is clear evidence that we need to act and we need to act now: please click here to donate.”

email us comments



printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list
Headlines


Pregnant Women Shouldn’t Swallow Mercury Scares
Posted On: Wednesday 11/12/2008

The Fish Is Fine (But The Mug May Kill You)
Posted On: Monday 10/27/2008

Is Something Fishy? Yep. Mercury-Scare Activists.
Posted On: Thursday 10/23/2008

Greenpeace Science: Fishy and Illiterate, As Usual
Posted On: Monday 10/13/2008

School of Fish (Thought) Swims Back To Common Sense
Posted On: Thursday 9/18/2008

Report: Mercury-Fish Hype Put Poor Children At Risk
Posted On: Wednesday 9/3/2008

Phony Health Experts Continue Seafood Smear Campaign
Posted On: Tuesday 5/13/2008

TV Talking Heads Rarely Major In Math. Or Science.
Posted On: Friday 4/25/2008

Time to Eat More Fish
Posted On: Thursday 4/10/2008


ActivistCash.com

SeaWeb
Background | Quotes | Financials
What can you say about a group of alarmist publicity-seekers whose greatest passion is “saving” fish species that aren’t even endangered? Sadly, SeaWeb is just one in a long line of recent entrants into the food-scare industry. read more here »

Sea Shepherd Conservation Society
Background | Quotes | Financials
Though self-named a “Conservation Society,” Sea Shepherd is a violent organization. “We’re not a protest organization, we’re a policing organization,” Paul Watson has said of his organization, however its purpose is to ram and sink ships making it more of a pirate crew. read more here »

Op-Eds

The mercury-in-the-fish story
Americans have been drowning in stories about “toxic” tuna sushi and high mercury levels in fish. read more here »

Mercury Risk? Scares mislead American consumers
How tiny are the traces of mercury in fish? University of Rochester scientists report in the New England Journal of Medicine that there haven't been any clinical reports of fish-related mercury poisoning since the 1950s and 1960s. read more here »


About Us | Contact Us | Please Help Us | Site Map
Ad Campaigns | Press Center | Daily News Archive | Email Subscription | Op-Eds | Cartoons | Games | Link To Us
Copyright © 1997-2008 Center for Consumer Freedom. Tel: 202-463-7112.